The Ultimate Guide: The Best Upper East Side Pizza Restaurants

Mimi's Pizza

217 East 86th St, New York, NY 10028

You can't have a list of the best pizza on the Upper East Side without mentioning Mimi's Pizza. They have a perfect selection of handmade specialty pizzas from the thick, hand-cut pepperoni on their Grandma pie to the popular buffalo chicken, chicken bacon ranch pizza. We'd also recommend that you try some of their pasta, salads, and appetizers like mozzarella sticks and garlic knots. Fun fact: Mimi's Pizza is one of our stops on our Upper East Side Food Tour and Upper West Side Food Tours.

Recommendations: Grandma slice, burrata pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, chicken bacon ranch pizza

Website: Mimi's Pizza

Emmy Squared Pizza

1426 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10028

Emmy's Pizza on the Upper East Side offers a fusion of different types of pizzas having combined a New York-style grandma pie with a Detroit style pizza. They have an extensive pizza menu and serve their gourmet pizza on a light and fluffy focaccia dough that is light and fluffy with a distinct crispy crust.

What to order: Truffle Shuffle Pizza, the Spicy Emmy, Rigatoni al Forno

Website: Emmy Squared Pizza

Delizia 92

1762 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128

Delizia 92 has been a staple on the Upper East Side since first opening in 1983, and for good reason. The Delizia 92 menu offers an extensive array of not only delectable pizzas but also cauliflower-crusted pizzettas, veal, seafood, poultry, and heroes. Indulge in their small white pizza, grandma alla vodka, or the generously topped large generosa pizza – a true feast for the senses.

What to order: White Pizza, Grandmda Alla Vodka Pizza, Generosa Pizza

Website: Delizia 92

San Matteo Upper East Side

1559 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028

San Matteo Upper East Side has been a beloved fixture on the Upper East Side since 2010, specializing in Neapolitan brick oven pizza and Panuozzi (a pizza-panini hybrid). In addition to their exceptional pizzas, they also offer house-made pasta and creative weekly specials. While at San Matteo, savor the flavors of their regina margherita, diavola, capricciosa, and burrata pizza – a true celebration of authentic Italian flavors.

Website: San Matteo

What to order: Regina Margherita Pizza, Diavola Pizza, Capricciosa Pizza

Gotham Pizza

1667 1st Ave., New York, NY 10028

Gotham Pizza is an iconic Upper East Side pizza spot and is offer arguably some of the best pizza on first avenue. Their flavorful crusted pizza slices, adorned with a tempting array of toppings, have become a hot spot for the locals. Whether you want a buffalo chicken slice, the veggie delight, or the classic pepperoni pizza, Gotham Pizza really does serve some of the best pizza on Upper East Side.

What to order: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza

Website: Gotham Pizza

Italian Village Pizza

1494 1st Ave. #1, New York, NY 10075

At Italian Village Pizza, the experience transcends mere pizza consumption. With an extensive menu featuring wings, francese flounder, pasta carbonara, and, of course, delectable pizza pies and slices, this establishment offers a fine dining ambiance paired with exceptional flavors. Indulge in their chicken and tomato pizza, artichoke pizza, sausage pizza, or the aptly named "everything pie" – a true feast for the senses.

What to order: Chicken and tomato pizza, artichoke pizza, sausage pizza

Website: Italian Village Pizza

Lexington Pizza Parlor

1590 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10029

If you search for best New York pizza near me on Google, chances are that Lexington Pizza Parlor will appear near the top of the list. This great little spot offers a sophisticated Italian bistro experience and its menu features traditional New York-style and gourmet brick oven pizzas, complemented by homemade Italian dishes like chicken parmigiana, penne vodka, and seasonal burrata. Indulge in the flavors of their authentic brick oven pizzas, such as the Di Buffalo and Arugula, Alla Vodka, or the Luna Piena – a true testament to the art of pizza-making.

Website: Lexington Pizza Parlor

What to order: Di Buffalo and Arugula Pizza, Alla Vodka Pizza, Luna Piena Pizza

Salvo's Pizza Bar

1477 York Ave, New York, NY 10075

Arriving on the Upper East Side in 2012, Salvo's Pizzabar has quickly become a neighborhood favorite, offering an authentic Italian kitchen and pizza experience. Their "Made with Amore" philosophy shines through in their Italian-American gourmet pizzas, calzones, and heroes. While at Salvo's, be sure to try the meat lovers pizza, chicken pizza, and chicken roll. For those with a sweet tooth, indulge in their decadent Nutella pizza – a truly unique and indulgent treat.

Website: Salvo's Pizza Bar

What to order: Meat Lovers Pizza, Nutella Pizza

Saba's Pizza

1443, 1217 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028

Sabas serves up the best thin crust pizza, offering Kosher pies by the slice, sandwiches, pasta, calzones, and more. This exceptional pizza shop operates from Sunday to Friday, serving up the best thin crust pizza Upper East Side has to offer. While at Saba's, be sure to try their grandma vodka pie, eggplant parm pizza, and VIP margarita. Also, if you're a Dave Portnoy fan you'll be pleased to know that El Presidente gave Saba's Pizza an 8.4.

Website: Saba's Pizza

What to order: Grandma vodka pizza, eggplant parm pizza

Marinara Pizza

1376 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10128

With five locations across the city, Marinara's Upper East Side outpost has become a hotspot for pizza, pasta, salads, and heroes. Their menu features a unique cauliflower crust pie, ensuring that every dietary preference is catered to. While at Marinara, be sure to try their MVP, vodka, grandma buffalo chicken pizza, and the irresistible chicken roll – a true testament to their culinary prowess.

Website: Marinara Pizza

What to order: MVP Pizza, Grandma Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Williamsburg Pizza

1617 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028

For those craving a taste of Brooklyn on the Upper East Side, Williamsburg Pizza is the perfect destination. This fun neighborhood spot offers a casual and inviting atmosphere, perfect for casual date nights, quick bites with friends, and more. While at Williamsburg Pizza, indulge in the Brooklyn LG, cup & char Grandma, Tartufo, and Apple Bacon pizza – a delightful fusion of flavors that will tantalize your taste buds.

Website: Williamsburg Pizza

What to order: Brooklyn Pizza, Tartufo Pizza

La Mia Pizza

1580 1st Ave., New York, NY 10028

La Mia Pizza takes pride in its diverse menu, ensuring that every customer finds their perfect slice. They arguably have some of the best gluten free pizza Upper East Side has to offer. As well as their gluten-free pizzas they also offer everything from whole wheat cheese pizza to classic Sicilian slices so their offerings cater to a wide range of dietary preferences and cravings. Savor the flavors of their grilled chicken caesar pizza, Hawaiian delight, meat lover's masterpiece, or the chicken francaise pizza.

Website: La Mia Pizza

What to order: Grilled Chicken Caesar Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Meat Lover's Pizza

Conclusion: Your guide to the best pizza in the Upper East Side

So there you have it folks, that's the full list of the best pizza Upper East Side Manhattan has to offer! With such a diverse array of pizza spots on the Upper East Side, each offering its own unique flavors, ambiance, and history, it's no wonder this neighborhood has become a mecca for pizza enthusiasts. Whether you're a lifelong New Yorker or a visitor seeking an authentic slice of the city's culinary culture, the Upper East Side promises a delectable journey through the world of pizza.